SugarStreetCafe Etsy shop, $17
Paloma's Nest Etsy Shop, $34 (various prices)
I looked up what I bought it for, and noticed her prices have gone up - I would too if I was featured by Martha! Here are some other options that might also float your boat. I couldn't narrow down my favorites, so I have a lot from each shop.
lovegrowsbygiving's Etsy Shop, $24 (various prices)
SayYourPiece's Etsy Shop, $8-$12 as shown
If feeling up to it, you can also try to make your own.
This is making me want to buy some more keepsake bowls/dishes. The last shop has some for babies and pets. Does my puppy need one? I could present her with her treats in her own fancy little dish.